Skip to content

LOCK IN 15% OFF WHEN YOU BUY TWO.

Avada Classic Shop
  • Home
  • Creepy Stuffed Animals
    • Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Animal
    • Huggy Wuggy Characters Plush
    • Nightmare Critters Plush
    • Smiling Critters Plush
    • Garten of Banban Plush
  • Poppy Playtime Merch
    • Huggy Wuggy Merch
    • Smiling Critters Merch
  • Tracking Order
  • Blog
  • Account
    • Register
  • Cart0
    • Sale!
      Realistic Monster Horror Stuffed Killy Willy Plush Realistic Monster Horror Stuffed Killy Willy Plush

      30cm Realistic Monster Horror Stuffed Killy Willy Plush

      $35.99 Original price was: $35.99.$26.99Current price is: $26.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      60 cm Poppy Playtime PJ Pug a Pillar Plush 60 cm Poppy Playtime PJ Pug a Pillar Plush

      60 cm Poppy Playtime PJ Pug a Pillar Plush

      $79.99 Original price was: $79.99.$59.99Current price is: $59.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Cute PJ Pug a Pillar Plush Pillow Doll 40 cm Cute PJ Pug a Pillar Plush Pillow Doll

      40 cm Cute PJ Pug a Pillar Plush Pillow Doll

      $66.99 Original price was: $66.99.$49.99Current price is: $49.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Spiderman Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy 40 cm Spiderman Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy

      40 cm Spiderman Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy

      $39.99 Original price was: $39.99.$29.99Current price is: $29.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Yellow Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy 40 cm Yellow Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy

      40 cm Yellow Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy

      $39.99 Original price was: $39.99.$29.99Current price is: $29.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Red Hat Poppy Playtime Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy 40 cm Red Hat Poppy Playtime Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy

      40 cm Red Hat Poppy Playtime Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy

      $39.99 Original price was: $39.99.$29.99Current price is: $29.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Mickey Mouse Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy 40 cm Mickey Mouse Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy

      40 cm Mickey Mouse Poppy Playtime Characters Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy

      $39.99 Original price was: $39.99.$29.99Current price is: $29.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      Mommy Long Leg Poppy Playtime Plush Toys

      40 cm Pink Mommy Long Leg Poppy Playtime Plush Toys

      $42.99 Original price was: $42.99.$31.99Current price is: $31.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      25cm Nightmare Critters Touille Plush 25cm Nightmare Critters Touille Plush

      25cm Nightmare Critters Touille Plush

      $42.69 Original price was: $42.69.$32.02Current price is: $32.02.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      25cm Nightmare Critters Rabie Baby 25cm Nightmare Critters Rabie Baby

      25cm Nightmare Critters Rabie Baby Plush

      $42.69 Original price was: $42.69.$32.02Current price is: $32.02.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      15cm Poppy Playtime Maggie Mako Plush 15cm Poppy Playtime Maggie Mako Plush

      15cm Poppy Playtime Maggie Mako Plush

      $27.55 Original price was: $27.55.$20.66Current price is: $20.66.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      15cm Poppy Playtime Simon Smoke Plush 15cm Poppy Playtime Simon Smoke Plush

      15cm Poppy Playtime Simon Smoke Plush

      $27.55 Original price was: $27.55.$20.66Current price is: $20.66.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      30cm Maggie Mako Plush 2 30cm Maggie Mako Plush 2

      30cm Maggie Mako Plush

      $41.11 Original price was: $41.11.$30.82Current price is: $30.82.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      30cm Simon Smoke Plush Doll 2 30cm Simon Smoke Plush Doll 2

      30cm Simon Smoke Plush Doll

      $41.11 Original price was: $41.11.$30.82Current price is: $30.82.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      30cm Allister Gator plush 2 30cm Allister Gator plush 2

      30cm Allister Gator plush

      $41.11 Original price was: $41.11.$30.82Current price is: $30.82.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sort by Rating
      • Sort by Default Order
      • Sort by Name
      • Sort by Price
      • Sort by Date
      • Sort by Popularity
      • Sort by Rating
    • Show 50 Products
      • Show 50 Products
      • Show 100 Products
      • Show 150 Products
    • Sale!
      Realistic Monster Horror Stuffed Killy Willy Plush Realistic Monster Horror Stuffed Killy Willy Plush

      30cm Realistic Monster Horror Stuffed Killy Willy Plush

      $35.99 Original price was: $35.99.$26.99Current price is: $26.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      60 cm Poppy Playtime PJ Pug a Pillar Plush 60 cm Poppy Playtime PJ Pug a Pillar Plush

      60 cm Poppy Playtime PJ Pug a Pillar Plush

      $79.99 Original price was: $79.99.$59.99Current price is: $59.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Cute PJ Pug a Pillar Plush Pillow Doll 40 cm Cute PJ Pug a Pillar Plush Pillow Doll

      40 cm Cute PJ Pug a Pillar Plush Pillow Doll

      $66.99 Original price was: $66.99.$49.99Current price is: $49.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Spiderman Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy 40 cm Spiderman Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy

      40 cm Spiderman Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy

      $39.99 Original price was: $39.99.$29.99Current price is: $29.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Yellow Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy 40 cm Yellow Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy

      40 cm Yellow Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy

      $39.99 Original price was: $39.99.$29.99Current price is: $29.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Red Hat Poppy Playtime Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy 40 cm Red Hat Poppy Playtime Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy

      40 cm Red Hat Poppy Playtime Huggy Wuggy Plush Stuffed Toy

      $39.99 Original price was: $39.99.$29.99Current price is: $29.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      40 cm Mickey Mouse Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy 40 cm Mickey Mouse Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy

      40 cm Mickey Mouse Poppy Playtime Characters Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Toy

      $39.99 Original price was: $39.99.$29.99Current price is: $29.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      Mommy Long Leg Poppy Playtime Plush Toys

      40 cm Pink Mommy Long Leg Poppy Playtime Plush Toys

      $42.99 Original price was: $42.99.$31.99Current price is: $31.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      25cm Nightmare Critters Touille Plush 25cm Nightmare Critters Touille Plush

      25cm Nightmare Critters Touille Plush

      $42.69 Original price was: $42.69.$32.02Current price is: $32.02.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      25cm Nightmare Critters Rabie Baby 25cm Nightmare Critters Rabie Baby

      25cm Nightmare Critters Rabie Baby Plush

      $42.69 Original price was: $42.69.$32.02Current price is: $32.02.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      15cm Poppy Playtime Maggie Mako Plush 15cm Poppy Playtime Maggie Mako Plush

      15cm Poppy Playtime Maggie Mako Plush

      $27.55 Original price was: $27.55.$20.66Current price is: $20.66.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      15cm Poppy Playtime Simon Smoke Plush 15cm Poppy Playtime Simon Smoke Plush

      15cm Poppy Playtime Simon Smoke Plush

      $27.55 Original price was: $27.55.$20.66Current price is: $20.66.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      30cm Maggie Mako Plush 2 30cm Maggie Mako Plush 2

      30cm Maggie Mako Plush

      $41.11 Original price was: $41.11.$30.82Current price is: $30.82.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      30cm Simon Smoke Plush Doll 2 30cm Simon Smoke Plush Doll 2

      30cm Simon Smoke Plush Doll

      $41.11 Original price was: $41.11.$30.82Current price is: $30.82.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      30cm Allister Gator plush 2 30cm Allister Gator plush 2

      30cm Allister Gator plush

      $41.11 Original price was: $41.11.$30.82Current price is: $30.82.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      Huggy Wuggy Poppy Playtime Mystery Box Huggy Wuggy Poppy Playtime Mystery Box

      Huggy Wuggy Poppy Playtime Mystery Box

      $35.98 – $36.98Price range: $35.98 through $36.98
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Sale!
      Kids Smiling Critters Birthday Decorations

      Kids Smiling Critters Birthday Decorations

      $32.01 – $43.95Price range: $32.01 through $43.95
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Out of stock
      Sale!
      Kids Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters Party Supplies Kids Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters Party Supplies

      Kids Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters Party Supplies

      $25.98 – $34.95Price range: $25.98 through $34.95
      Details
    • Sale!
      Pianosaurus Stuffed Plush Toy Pianosaurus Stuffed Plush Toy

      Poppy Playtime Chapter 4 Pianosaurus Stuffed Plush Toy

      $47.07 Original price was: $47.07.$32.95Current price is: $32.95.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      Yarnaby Nightmare Critters Cotton Tee Yarnaby Nightmare Critters Cotton Tee

      Yarnaby Nightmare Critters Cotton Tee

      $24.42 – $28.93Price range: $24.42 through $28.93
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Sale!
      size chart shirt Cartoon Print Kids Summer Smiling Critters Tee and Shorts Set

      Cartoon Print Kids Summer Smiling Critters Tee and Shorts Set

      $30.95 – $36.15Price range: $30.95 through $36.15
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Sale!
      Kids Short Sleeve Smiling Critters T-shirt Kids Short Sleeve Smiling Critters T-shirt

      Kids Short Sleeve Smiling Critters T-shirt

      $20.93 – $22.93Price range: $20.93 through $22.93
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Sale!
      Summer Two-piece Set Short-sleeved Poppy Playtime Shirt Summer Two-piece Set Short-sleeved Poppy Playtime Shirt

      Summer Two-piece Set Short-sleeved Poppy Playtime Shirt

      $24.93 – $29.04Price range: $24.93 through $29.04
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Sale!
      28 cm Poppy Playtime Chapter 3 Miss Delight Plush Toy 1 28 cm Poppy Playtime Chapter 3 Miss Delight Plush Toy 1

      28 cm Poppy Playtime Chapter 3 Miss Delight Plush Toy

      $39.96 Original price was: $39.96.$29.97Current price is: $29.97.
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      Comfortable 3D Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters Blanket Comfortable 3D Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters Blanket

      Comfortable 3D Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters Blanket

      $30.45 – $107.99Price range: $30.45 through $107.99
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Sale!
      Comfy Catnap Dogday Pillowcase Smiling Critters Pillow Cover Comfy Catnap Dogday Pillowcase Smiling Critters Pillow Cover

      Comfy Catnap Dogday Pillowcase Smiling Critters Pillow Cover

      $21.93 – $32.95Price range: $21.93 through $32.95
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Sale!
      Nightmare Critter Cosplay Doey The Doughmans Costume Nightmare Critter Cosplay Doey The Doughmans Costume

      Nightmare Critter Cosplay Doey The Doughmans Costume

      $76.08 – $86.99Price range: $76.08 through $86.99
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Sale!
      Nightmare Critter Cosplay Yarnaby Costume Nightmare Critter Cosplay Yarnaby Costume

      Nightmare Critter Cosplay Yarnaby Costume

      $76.08 – $86.99Price range: $76.08 through $86.99
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • Sale!
      Nightmare Critter Cosplay Pianosaurus Costume Nightmare Critter Cosplay Pianosaurus Costume

      Nightmare Critter Cosplay Pianosaurus Costume

      $76.08 – $86.99Price range: $76.08 through $86.99
      Add To Cart This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Details
    • 18cm Pianosauruses Plush 18cm Pianosauruses Plush

      18cm Pianosauruses Plush

      $26.75
      Add to cart Details
    • 28cm Doeys The Doughman Toy Plushies 28cm Doeys The Doughman Toy Plushies

      28cm Doeys The Doughman Toy Plushies

      $28.99
      Add to cart Details
    • 31cm Poppy Playtime Doey The Doughman Plush Toy 31cm Poppy Playtime Doey The Doughman Plush Toy

      31cm Poppy Playtime Doey The Doughman Plush Toy

      $28.99
      Add to cart Details
    • 27cm Nightmare Critters Plush Toy Cloudboy Game Plushies 27cm Nightmare Critters Plush Toy Cloudboy Game Plushies

      27cm Nightmare Critters Plush Toy Cloudboy Game Plushies

      $27.25
      Add to cart Details
    • 34cm Nightmare Critters Plush Toy Pink Doey The Doughman 34cm Nightmare Critters Plush Toy Pink Doey The Doughman

      34cm Nightmare Critters Plush Toy Pink Doey The Doughman

      $30.98
      Add to cart Details
    • kf S922f539d930b477ebe3aa8bc18273ebfk

      30cm Poppy Playtime Chapter 4 Doey the Doughman Plush Toy

      $29.55
      Add to cart Details
    • 22cm Pianosaurus Pillow Nightmare Critters Piano Dragon Plush 22cm Pianosaurus Pillow Nightmare Critters Piano Dragon Plush

      22cm Pianosaurus Pillow Nightmare Critters Piano Dragon Plush

      $44.59
      Add to cart Details
    • 23cm Deluxe Posable Yarnaby Plush 23cm Deluxe Posable Yarnaby Plush

      23cm Deluxe Posable Yarnaby Plush

      $45.28
      Add to cart Details
    • 21cm Rainbow Tail Cat - Poppy Playtime Yarnabelle Plush Toy

      21cm Rainbow Tail Cat – Poppy Playtime Yarnabelle Plush Toy

      $35.99
      Add to cart Details
    • 24 cm Green Rabbit Garten of Banban Plush Toy 24 cm Green Rabbit Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      26 cm Green Rabbit Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $24.99
      Add to cart Details
    • 27cm Crabbler Garten of Banban Plush Toy 27cm Crabbler Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      27cm Crabbler Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $26.99
      Add to cart Details
    • 19cm One-eyed Green Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy 19cm One-eyed Green Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      19cm One-eyed Green Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $23.98
      Add to cart Details
    • 20 cm Purple Three Eyes Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy 20 cm Purple Three Eyes Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      20 cm Purple Three Eyes Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $24.97
      Add to cart Details
    • 22cm Blue Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy 22cm Blue Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      22cm Blue Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $25.78
      Add to cart Details
    • 25 cm Red Two Head Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy 25 cm Red Two Head Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      25 cm Red Two Head Monster Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $26.56
      Add to cart Details
    • 16 cm Remy Garten of Banban Plush Toy 16 cm Remy Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      16 cm Remy Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $23.76
      Add to cart Details
    • 25 cm Crab Clarence Garten of Banban Plush Toy 25 cm Crab Clarence Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      25 cm Crab Clarence Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $26.65
      Add to cart Details
    • Sale!
      25 cm Purple Opila Bird Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      25 cm Purple Opila Bird Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $35.98 Original price was: $35.98.$26.99Current price is: $26.99.
      Add to cart Details
    • 30 cm Okegztoa Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      30 cm Okegztoa Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $42.99
      Add to cart Details
    • 20 cm Four Eyed Pink Pig Garten of Banban Plush Toy 20 cm Four Eyed Pink Pig Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      20 cm Four Eyed Pink Pig Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      $23.76
      Add to cart Details
    • kf Sc1377b2d674546148bc03da01157e6fcC

      20 cm Doom Doom Garten of Banban Plush Toy

      Details
    1 2 … 6 Next

    Product Search

    Filter by price

    Price: —

    Shop By Category

    • Huggy Wuggy Merchandise
    • Huggy Wuggy Characters Plush
    • Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Animal
    • Smiling Critters Merchandise
    • Smiling Critters Plush
    • Garten of Banban Plush

    SHOP

    • Huggy Wuggy Merchandise
    • Huggy Wuggy Characters Plush
    • Huggy Wuggy Stuffed Animal
    • Smiling Critters Merchandise
    • Smiling Critters Plush
    • Garten of Banban Plush

    SERVICE & SUPPORT

    • Shipping Policy
    • Refund and Returns Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    COMPANY INFOMATION

     

    • Terms of service
    • About Us
    • Contact Us

    Head Office: 1225 Cypress Ave

    Los Angeles, CA 90065

    Phone: (312) 319-5957
    Email: info@fivestartoy.com

    © Five Star Toy, 2025 All Rights Reserved.

    payment cards footer
    Page load link
    0
    YOUR CART
    • No products in the cart.
    Subtotal:
    $0.00
    CHECKOUT
    BEST SELLING PRODUCTS
    Huggy Wuggy Ear Moving Hat
    Huggy Wuggy Ear Moving Hat
    $19.99 – $37.99Price range: $19.99 through $37.99
    40 cm Tiger Stripe Huggy Wuggy Plushies
    40 cm Tiger Stripe Huggy Wuggy Plushies
    $47.99 Original price was: $47.99.$35.99Current price is: $35.99.
    Decoration Set for Poppy Playtime Birthday Party & Game
    Decoration Set for Poppy Playtime Birthday Party & Game
    $35.99 – $39.99Price range: $35.99 through $39.99
    Poppy Playtime Chapter 4 Pianosaurus Stuffed Plush Toy
    Poppy Playtime Chapter 4 Pianosaurus Stuffed Plush Toy
    $47.07 Original price was: $47.07.$32.95Current price is: $32.95.
    25cm Poppy Playtime Boogie Bot Stuffed Toy
    25cm Poppy Playtime Boogie Bot Stuffed Toy
    $55.99 Original price was: $55.99.$41.99Current price is: $41.99.
    Go to Top